|
Monk’s first record for Columbia could be accused of being a safe bet since it features a selection of
classic Monk tunes instead of new material. However, don’t dismiss it too quickly. On the original
recordings of these songs, the pianist played as if he was chiseling the tunes out of marble, and part
of
the fun was listening to what seemed very much like composition in progress. These recordings, on
the other hand, sound more like finished sculptures or polished works of art.
Perhaps Monk sensed
that this would be the last time he would record these tunes in the studio, or maybe Macero gave
him more takes to hone a flawless performance. Nevertheless, Criss Cross was (and is) a
great way
for listeners unfamiliar with Monk to experience him for the first time in slightly low-key performances
of classic Monk tunes. None of the songs exceeds four minutes and offer an excellent cross section
of Monk’s artistry, from the lively “Hackensack” to the artfully constructed “Criss Cross” with a couple
of standards thrown in, of course. “Crepuscle With Nellie” is arguably the best rendition of the tune,
with Charlie Rouse displaying an empathy and understanding that not even Sonny Rollins could
find. Monk may have had more interesting sidemen in his past, but Rouse gave the group a
reliability it previously never had. However, “Pannonica” (not on the original LP release but added
as a bonus track to the previous CD reissue) meanders too long and “Coming on the Hudson” (a
brand new bonus track for this release) is a complicated tune on which not even Rouse can find
footing. At any rate, an excellent fresh start.
For related reviews, see
Combing the Columbia/Legacy Catalog.
~ David Rickert
|
Track Listing: 1. Hackensack 2. Tea For Two 3. Criss Cross 4. Eronel 5. Rhythm-A-Ning 6. Don’t Blame Me 7.
Think Of One 8. Crepuscle With Nellie 9. Pannonica 10. Coming on the Hudson 11. Tea For Two
(alt. Take) 12. Eronel (alt. take).
Personnel: 1. Hackensack 2. Tea For Two 3. Criss Cross 4. Eronel 5. Rhythm-A-Ning 6. Don’t Blame Me 7.
Think Of One 8. Crepuscle With Nellie 9. Pannonica 10. Coming on the Hudson 11. Tea For Two
(alt. Take) 12. Eronel (alt. take).
|
